Final Transit: Priyank Thatte’s personal weblog and travelog
Scrolls from the Holy Land - 4 : Mount of Olives : Older post Newer post : Scrolls from the Holy Land - 6 : Old City of Jerusalem
Jan '08
20

Scrolls from the Holy Land - 5 : Bethlehem

This blog post is part of my Israel travelog series. I spent 3 weeks in Israel during Dec’07-Jan’08 and all my travel stories and pictures are recorded on this website. Please visit the Index page by clicking here to get a complete Israel travelogue. Thanks :)

img_2457.jpg

Way down in the land of Judea,
God sent to the earth a Savior, for all men
One star for the Holy Light,
Jesus was born in Bethlehem.

From Jerusalem to Bethlehem:
img_2458.jpgBethlehem, being in Palestinian territory, is served by the Arab bus network. From the terminal near Damascus gate, bus # 21 goes directly to the stop near the church of Nativity. However, for some reason I was boarding bus # 124 probably because I asked the wrong question. Just like me, there was a couple from Mexico and a guy from Korea. Just a note: Bus 124 does go to Bethlehem, but - not to the place you wanna go. The correct question to ask is - “Which bus goes to Church of Nativity in Bethlehem?” ;)

It was too late by the time we realized that we were in the wrong bus. We found ourselves dumped at a check post in some unknown part of Bethlehem. Fortunately we met a German guy who was volunteering at the church and was passing through that place - he showed us the right way. It was a long 30 minute walk - almost felt like a pilgrimage! I was glad we took the wrong bus, how else would I have seen the real (i.e. non-touristy) Bethlehem town? But, for a non-adventurous traveller the moral of the story is - take bus #21 from Jerusalem, it costs 11 NIS and is the best way to go in my view.

Narrow streets that lead to the church of nativity
Market on the path to Church of Nativity


The Church of Nativity is accessible only on foot. There IS a road, but it is lengthy and inconvenient, so most people prefer to walk (except the large tour buses). Even the bus #21 drops you at some distance away from the Manger square where the church is located. It is a pleasurable walk thru narrow alleys full of shops on either sides. The cost of goods was, in general, lower that that in Jerusalem (for example, the Jerusalem bread cost only 3.5 NIS as opposed to 5 NIS in Jerusalem). It was fun to walk thru the market, and every five minutes there was either a chapel or a mosque.

Church of Nativity:
Virgin Mary and Jesus in Church of Nativity
Virgin Mary and baby Jesus in Church of Nativity


img_2461.jpgThis church is one of the oldest Churches in the world that is still operational. It is built over a cave that is believed to be the birth place of Jesus Christ. This church is administered jointly by the Greek Orthodox, Roman Catholic and Armenian Apostolic branches. The guidebook I used said that all the three styles are identifyable. However, I am not architecturally endowed, so it all looked the same to me. As the case of most other historical sites in Israel, this site too was built, destroyed and rebuilt img_2472.jpgover the past 1500 years. I was in Bethleham just two days before Christmas, and it was nice to see shops and houses decorated, not to mention truckloads of devotees.

Birthplace of Jesus Christ:
img_2468.jpg
An array of photo frames and idols of various figures, crosses, worshiped using flowers and lighting of oil lamps. There is a marked symbol looking like Sun over which people rest their heads - touching that symbolic representation of God is very important. People push you around in the zeal to grab a quick view (darshan?) of the holy place. The place of worship itself is underground in a damp and stuffy chamber. You are supposed to clean your feet before entering. Wearing a cap is prohibited. The priest doesn’t allow you to linger there and hurriedly thrusts a bit of holy food (prasad?) on your palm before signaling you to move out.
img_2469.jpg
Wait a minute - did you think that I was describing some Hindu temple? No, I wasn’t, infact I was telling you exactly how it was in the core of this Church! The lines of distinctions between religious worship are not as deep as we think, are they?
img_2473.jpg
My visit to the Church of Nativity (and Israel in general) exposed me to a whole new world of Christian symbolism and iconography. In the pictures above, the star symbol was the exact place where it is believed that baby Jesus was born. Immediately after birth, the baby was lifted and placed on a manger because Joseph and Mary were too poor to afford anything luxurious. That’s the white platform in the picture.
img_2475.jpg
The church is really old and is preserved in that fashion. As soon as you enter the church, there is a large open square with complex arrays of lamps hanging on either sides and all over the church in general. The walls are decaying but the golden mosaic can still be seen. The pillars, largely worn out have delicate paintings on them. The whole place gave me a very distinct feeling that I am just a tiny dot in the universe. Suddenly, I discovered that I have unknowingly joined my hands to pray.

I am glad I visited the place where Jesus Christ was born. It is rare for ‘others’ to visit this shrine.

People:
img_2480.jpgThe Korean guy was lost and the Mexican couple was very religious, so they probably spent more time in the Churches around. There is nothing else really important in Bethlehem other than this place so I was on my way back. Meanwhile, I met this European guy while I was having some Arabic coffee in one of the shacks on streets. People were naturally curious about us and it was very entertaining to talk to them. One of the local Arab guys knew a Hindi song from the 80’s and was delighted to sing it (it took me a while to understand what he was saying!)

Salespeople! Ah, well, I missed the aggressive Indian-style sales tactics since I came to Canada last year. It was the same, same old technique that is so common in India. People will pursue you and virtually beg you to buy their stuff. As an MBA student taking ‘negotiations’ courses, all their tactics fascinate me. The little kids always seem to know what price a person is willing to pay, and they are excellent negotiators! One girl even said, ‘Your girlfriend will love it’ - they know exactly what to say (well, almost ;) )


Manger square in Bethlehem
Manger square in Bethlehem, directly in front is the Mosque of Omar

img_2481.jpgThere is a famous ‘wall’ that separates the West Bank area from rest of Israel. Every vehicle from Palestine to Israel is stopped at the checkpoint - every passenger has to exit the vehicle, stand in a queue and get his ID’s checked by Israeli soldiers. They also check the vehicles. It seemed just another thing for the Palestinians but I was trying to imagine a similar situation in India. I think we must pause and appreciate the freedom that we enjoy regardless of our religion (in India, or the rest of the democratic nations in general), because not all the people in the world get the same.
img_2482.jpg
There was a separate queue for foreigners (just the two of us). I met a soldier of Indian origin at the border checkpost and had an interesting conversation with him (will post later) .

Soon the bus navigated to Jerusalem and dropped me off at Jaffa gate - The main entrance to the old city…

And that’s going to be my next blog: Old city of Jerusalem.

Beginning composition by New hope Music

This blog post is part of my Israel travelog series. I spent 3 weeks in Israel during Dec’07-Jan’08 and all my travel stories and pictures are recorded on this website. Please visit the Index page by clicking here to get a complete Israel travelogue. Thanks :)
Related posts


16 Responses to “Scrolls from the Holy Land - 5 : Bethlehem”. Add Yours

  1. Nandan says:

    Must have been quite exciting getting a chance to speak in your mother-tongue at such an unexpected place and time. The travelogue so far, has a nice flow. Waiting for the next parts :)

  2. Yair says:

    You know as an Israeli it is unsafe to travel to those areas. Thanks for the nice virtual tour of this place.

  3. Yair says:

    There is a Jewish place called Rachel’s Tomb located near Bethlehem btw, and there are some more smaller Christian sites around the city. But you are right, this church is the most important.

  4. Priyank says:

    Nandan:
    Welcome to Priyank.com and nice to see your comment after a long time. I edited the current blog and removed my conversation with the soldiers because it was not related to Bethlehem, I’ll post it later!

    Yair:
    I have heard most Israelis say that. I knew there were some places near Bethlehem, but I had other reasons to get back to Jerusalem that day.

  5. ritr007 says:

    this was a good post, are hindi temples also like that? did you attend the service or christmas mass?

  6. backpakker says:

    this is the best in the series …the pictures were awesome..and I liked the way you wrote that suddenly your palms joined together to pray..

    Pls scroll down to the last para of my post..you will find something of interest to you

  7. kasakaay says:

    So did your girl friend like it :D?

  8. Raji says:

    Your travelogues are better than your movie reviews.
    Tho both are written in equal details; may be I feel this way bcoz travel interests me, and our interest in movies differ : )
    anyway…

    Liking this series.
    Wish we all in the world could see the similarities in our religions. That really seemed to be a temple description!
    and I bowed my head to that picture of sun there.
    Doesn’t harm me in any way!
    Happy to be born in a secular country.

  9. Priyank says:

    Rick (ritr007):
    Thanks. Many Hindu (note the word) temples are like that. I did not attend the service since I went there 2 days before Christmas.

    Lakshmi (backpakker):
    wow, thanks!
    And I commented on your post too :)

  10. Priyank says:

    kasakay:
    Welcome to my blog. Kasa kay?? (hehehe)
    Well I didn’t buy anything from her, so I don’t know ;)

    Raji:
    I guess - out travel interests do match! To tell you honestly, I was asked many times why I was visiting Christian or Jewish or Muslim religious places. My answer to them was simple - my religion does not stop me from doing that, so as you said, “why not?” :)

  11. Celine says:

    “I think we must pause and appreciate the freedom that we enjoy regardless of our religion (in India, ..”

    I’m not here to discuss politics and opine on who has the right of sovereignty over whom, however, reading your post reminded me of the time when I visited Lebanon in 1994. That time I felt exactly like you conveyed here when I noticed the old Lebanese driver of the taxi we were in was being subjected to security inspections at various check points by Syrian soldiers in Lebanon. Each time he had to get down from the taxi while the tourist passengers (us, Indians) were not questioned.

    Such incidents make us all the more appreciative the value of the freedom we enjoy that we take for granted otherwise. That’s why I keep harping endlessly on how great India is. To me, the thought of 1.2 billion people living, more or less, harmoniously and freely in a pluralistic society is commendable.

    Priyank, don’t know if I should refrain from hitting the ’submit’ button here or apologize for this lengthy comment.

    Thank you for this excellent post full of interesting information and splendid pictures. :)

  12. Priyank says:

    Cellu,
    The comment box is very happy because its purpose is being met. Please dont hesitate ever to post your comment here.
    Your similar personal experience has made this post richer indeed, and probably thats exactly how I felt :)

  13. Shoshana says:

    Hi

    Waiting for your stories on Tel Aviv Yafo.

  14. leena elizabeth abraham says:

    Hi,
    I just returned from Israel last week (18–5-08)..loved the place and saw most of the places that you have mentioned in your web page.. in fact i read your web pages beforw I went… you have good pics.. and I got a good idea of the places because of that..
    The church of the nativity and The church of the Holy Sepulchre are my favourites…

  15. Priyank says:

    Shoshi: Yeah, I don’t know when I will post that :( Maybe after finishing Peru series… Sorry to keep you waiting..

  16. Priyank says:

    Leena: Welcome again. I am glad the information posted here was useful - now that makes it totally worth all the pain of blogging :) Thanks so much for letting me know.

Please comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Scrolls from the Holy Land - 4 : Mount of Olives : Older post Newer post : Scrolls from the Holy Land - 6 : Old City of Jerusalem